Case Studies
Case Studies
An $8B leader in personal and commercial insurance services required assistance in re-sourcing their existing Application Maintenance & Support (AMS).
CHALLENGES
Incumbent provider consistently missing agreed upon service delivery agreements
Lack of focus by incumbent provider and unwillingness/inability to provide quality resources for the engagement
Benchmarks showed above-market pricing for existing engagement resource parameters
Incumbent provider unable to handle new technology platform currently under development
SCOPE
Legacy AMS activities for ~60 policy, billing, and claims applications
Modern AMS activities for Guidewire policy, billing & claims application & supporting applications
APPROACH
ITSE assessed client’s goals and objectives for the next iteration of their outsourcing through workshops to develop and document Key Business Decisions (KBDs) with the IT executive team
ITSE worked with stakeholders to rapidly gather all information related to the existing AMS engagement along with the Modern AMS requirements
ITSE conducted a market scan of solutions to determine which suppliers could potentially support the client’s needs under a tight timeline
ITSE worked with the client to identify the scope and functional requirements needed
ITSE created all RFP documents, issued RFPs to three leading suppliers in the space, and facilitated the beginning-to-end sourcing, evaluation, due diligence and selection process
ITSE created supplier evaluations to score suppliers in various categories in order to identify the best supplier for client’s needs
ITSE led negotiations and assisted Client Legal department in the development and finalization of all contractual documents.
KEY RESULTS
32% total 3-year engagement savings over incumbent provider
Funded AMS engagement for Modern Applications with savings from Legacy AMS
3-year fixed price agreement with built in YoY cost reductions; optional years 4 & 5 fixed price pre-negotiated
Negotiated rate card for additional services and locked for three years (no increases)
Extremely high client satisfaction
A leading $7B global provider of food safety and security, facility hygiene, and product protection wanted to consolidate its existing scope of providers to a manageable portfolio for Application Development Management (ADM), specifically focused on Development, Deployment & Integration (DDI) space.
CHALLENGES
Reduce costs by at least 15%
Improve working capital and supplier performance
Reset pricing model to current market conditions
Consolidate IT consulting services suppliers
SCOPE
Categories in scope: IT ADM services specifically related to DDI workloads
Region: Global
APPROACH
ITSE conducted an assessment of client’s portfolio of existing suppliers
Identified opportunities to reduce costs by introducing new competition and by consolidating to a small panel of qualified, global providers
ITSE conducted a competitive RFP process that included all incumbent suppliers and also included several new competitors
ITSE facilitated the RFP evaluation process with client’s Core Evaluation Team to down-select the list of potential suppliers based on their written RFP responses
Conducted Workshops with remaining suppliers and further down-selected based on outcomes of these Workshops and requested best-and-final-offers (BAFOs) incorporating provided feedback
ITSE facilitated the negotiation process of BAFOs and Core Team aligned on split award for ADM services among the top 3 suppliers
KEY RESULTS
18% annual savings
Established a panel of qualified suppliers including several new suppliers for ADM services
Established a formal process for evaluating & awarding new projects to the selected suppliers
Rate cards guaranteed for two years without increases
Extremely high client satisfaction
A $2B leader in Education & Learning services required assistance in re-negotiating and restructuring their existing Application Maintenance & Support (AMS) and Application Development Management (ADM) engagement with their incumbent provider.
CHALLENGES
Incumbent provider reports all “green” on Service Level Agreements (SLAs) but reporting is skewed as a one-size-fits-all model
Lack of focus by incumbent provider on the “right work” - oversized AMS Team with undersized ADM team
Benchmarks from ITSE showed above-market pricing for existing engagement resource parameters
Incumbent provider is too entangled in current workload delivery to be removed – desire is to re-negotiate if possible
Current engagement model does not have the right mix of Onsite:Offshore, especially on ADM side to fully support Agile and distributed development processes
SCOPE
Legacy AMS activities for all applications
ADM activities for new application development activities
North America
APPROACH
ITSE assessed client’s goals and objectives for the next iteration of their outsourcing through workshops to develop and document Key Business Decisions (KBDs) with the IT executive team
ITSE worked with stakeholders to rapidly gather all information related to the existing AMS engagement along with the Modern AMS requirements
ITSE led the re-classification of the AMS Application Portfolio into Critical / Non-critical and Gold / Silver / Bronze (based on Business Value) in order to drive to appropriate focus from the Supplier based on these new classifications
ITSE led negotiations to “right-size” and “right-location” the resource mix of core AMS resources to drive a leaner AMS Team, and thereby improving efficiencies and reducing legacy maintenance costs
Client also decided to remove Enhancements altogether from the AMS engagement which reduced the AMS Scope to only Break/Fix Support and Maintenance Only - Enhancements become part of the ADM engagement
Client optimized the Core ADM Team to “right-size” and “right-location” mix of core ADM resources. Large Enhancements and Project Work to be treated as ADM activities billed directly to the Business. All other IT resource needs committed on project-by-project basis – May utilize incumbent Supplier or other “preferred” suppliers at Client’s discretion
ITSE developed a holistic & centralized Governance model across towers at a program level (AMS & ADM). Client created a new internal position for Supplier Engagement Lead to manage the entire AMS/ADM engagement
ITSE led negotiations and assisted Client Legal department in the development and finalization of all contractual documents.
KEY RESULTS
23% total 3-year engagement savings by renegotiating with incumbent provider
Right-sized and Right-located all AMS & ADM Supplier resources to improve overall operational efficiencies
Refocusing of AMS effort towards Gold Applications to ensure core systems remain attended to
3-year fixed price agreement with built in YoY cost reductions; optional years 4 & 5 fixed price pre-negotiated
Negotiated rate card for additional services and locked for three years (no increases)
Extremely high client satisfaction
A $19B multinational manufacturer and marketer of home appliances required assistance in the initial outsourcing of their Application Maintenance Services (AMS) and Application Development Management (ADM) domain areas.
CHALLENGES
Issues include plethora of handoffs among over 50 IT Service Providers in the current model
Sourcing objectives include; Cost savings, Access to enhanced skillsets, Productivity improvements for both AMS and ADM, and increased throughput
Client had not previously outsourced IT so challenges also included first time contract development, HR related issues with transfer of personnel, and overall Change Management for the organization
Desire to increase the offshore numbers that include a significant number of sustained resources to maximize the resource knowledge base
SCOPE
Legacy AMS activities for ~600 Applications and ~500 Interface points
North America focus with some Regional impacts
APPROACH
ITSE assessed client’s goals and objectives for the first iteration of their outsourcing future-state organization through workshops to develop and document Key Business Decisions (KBDs) with the IT executive team
ITSE worked with stakeholders to rapidly gather all information related to the existing AMS engagement along with the new development requirements
ITSE conducted a market scan of solutions to determine which suppliers could potentially support the client’s needs under a tight timeline
ITSE worked with the client to identify the scope and functional requirements needed to build out a very detailed RFP Package that included both AMS and ADM requirements to be provided by a single Service Provider
ITSE created all RFP documents, issued RFPs to five leading suppliers in the space, and facilitated the beginning-to-end sourcing, evaluation, due diligence and selection process
ITSE created supplier evaluations to score suppliers in various categories in order to identify the best supplier for client’s needs
ITSE led negotiations and assisted Client Legal department in the development and finalization of all contractual documents.
KEY RESULTS
33% total 3-year engagement savings over in-house IT department funded resources (transitioned 40 resources to Service Provider)
Developed a new Governance group within Client IT organization to monitor and manage the Service Provider ongoing
3-year fixed price agreement with built in YoY cost reductions; optional years 4 & 5 fixed price pre-negotiated
Negotiated rate card for additional services and locked for three years (no increases)
Extremely high client satisfaction